Friday, 2 April 2021

Christian Comprehensiveness

by D. Ray Heisey

The writer to the Hebrews develops one major argument throughout his epistle. His argument is this: There is a kind of tide drifting you away from Christ; therefore, be careful to keep on due course.

In his analysis of this drift, the writer suggests at least four causes, one being formalism. The community to which he was writing, located probably near Rome, had been observing the forms of religion so long that the forms were becoming ends in themselves. Another cause was familiarity with religious facts. The community had grown sluggish; they had made Jesus Christ dull. A third cause was a combination of persecution and disillusionment. A storm had snapped their moorings and they had dragged their anchors. Rome had reversed its position toward Christians and some were persecuted and some were losing heart and hope in regard to the parousia. A fourth cause was complacency. Formalism, familiarity, and disappointment all tumbled together. Spiritual stagnation was inevitable. The community had an arrested development of Christian faith. It was staying static.

I don’t think I need to spend much time suggesting the contemporaneousness of this analysis of Hebrews for our religious situation today. We hear no end of opinions about the state of Christianity and the organized church. It would appear, however, that there are four major answers people are giving. I would like to examine these responses and then show how remarkably they correspond to the correctives which the writer to the Hebrews offered.

First, there are the Christian radicals who say the church is sick and what it needs to do is to break with its theological past and its institutional life.[1] The spokesmen for this point of view are numerous. Let me cite four of the many who could be quoted. In 1963, J. A. T. Robinson’s book HONEST TO GOD[2] called into question many of the basic assumptions which Christians had held for years. “The first thing we must be ready to let go,” he said, “is our image of God himself.” The death of God theology became very popular.

In 1965, Harvey Cox’s THE SECULAR CITY claimed that “we must learn… to speak of God in a secular fashion and find a non-religious interpretation of biblical concepts. It will do no good to cling to our religious versions of Christianity in the hope that one day religion will once again be back.” It is disappearing forever, he said, and that means we can now let go and immerse ourselves “in the new world of the secular city.”[3]

The next year, 1966, Joseph Fletcher published SITUATION ETHICS: THE NEW MORALITY. This book was called “racy,” “blood-chilling,” “a watershed in the history of moral theology,” and “another example of the rebellion of fallen man against his creator.” In any moral decision, Fletcher argued, the key question is: “What does God’s love demand of me in this particular situation?” It was hailed as “a manifesto of individual freedom and individual responsibility, elaborated within an ethic of love, which extricates modern man from rigid, archaic rules and codes.”[4]

In 1967, Robert Jenson, in his book, A RELIGION AGAINST ITSELF, said that there seem to be more and more people who believe in Christ and yet wish there were some way of believing other than being religious. He called our supernaturalism fraudulent, and continued:

The religious mimicry of our congregations, the rhetoric of our denominations, the theologies of our Sunday schools, the pseudo-divine personifications of our economic ideologies together with the bloody war-liturgies of their worship, the Sunday-morning-radio “Spark of the divine in every man,” Sallman’s Jesus and “My God and I” share one common feature: they all make one sick, and in exactly the same way that celluloid carnations and “lifetime” Christmas trees make one sick. They are unmistakably phony.[5]

The Radical Christianity response to the sickness of the church is similar to the response of student rebels in our colleges and universities. There is the growing conviction that the existing institutions, as now constituted—whether the university, the church, or the political party—cannot effectively adapt to the urgent needs of the contemporary situation. The only alternative is to abandon them. A matrix of frustration and anguish is producing a community committed to radical changes.

A second way of responding to the diagnosis is this. The chinch is sick but what we need to do is not break with the past but go back to it —to the faith once delivered to the saints. We need to renounce the modern attempts to make Christ relevant and stop allowing the church to be shaped so much by the world’s mold. Leon Sutch, pastor of the Epworth Methodist Church in Elgin, Ill., puts it this way:

On the theological right are those who would retreat into the past, by a resurgence of fundamentalism. Affronted by the church’s involvement in civil rights, the war on poverty and peace movements, and afraid of the rapid change of events around them, many laymen find this retreat a near-perfect solution to their problems. It arouses warm memories of childhood, absolves them from responsibility for the world, reassures them that God is just where he was yesterday.[6]

In a recent book called, RELEVANCE: THE ROLE OF CHRISTIAITY IN THE 20th CENTURY, Richard Halverson says, “Because humanity’s problem is congenital sin in the human heart—there is only one solution.. What is the answer to this broken world?… The Bible answer, the intelligent answer; the one adequate answer, can be summed up in a word, ‘reconciliation’ … Jesus Christ knew that war and death were due to a malignancy in the human heart which could be cured only by His own sacrifice on the cross. He entered ,history and determined a course that ultimately took him to the cross to solve this root problem once and for all—forever.”[7]

A third way of responding to the sickness of the church is … the church isn’t sick, the critics are simply using the wrong criteria for judging.[8] They tend to think of the church as merely one among all the other causes, institutions, and idealisms. When the word “cause” is used to describe Christianity, it reduces the church to everything else we think about as a cause. So, we are inclined to think, says Paul Holmer of Yale Divinity School, that the church too “lives by money, thrives with planning, prospers with clever and brainy people, needs widespread support to get its work done, and, above all, needs to progress and to change with the age.”[9]

Most movements or causes can be judged by results. Are they accomplishing anything? Are Negroes in Alabama voting? Is open housing in Cleveland a reality? Is the war in Vietnam de-escalating? Is the draft law being changed? Are students being placed on faculty committees and given a voice in building curriculum? These are legitimate questions for members of human causes designed to bring immediate results.

But then we tend to use the results theory with the church. Are we growing numerically? How many new members did the church have last year? How much increase was there in the budget? Such questions mean we are thinking of the church as any other cause. It is like a business. There is, of course, a place for recognizing the similarities between the church and other institutions. But differences are much more important. Again, Paul Holmer says:

The strangeness of the churches is safeguarded best when it is realized that one does not live so much for the harvest as one does for the quality of the sowing. To believe in God is to be able to conceive of the whole of life as a time of sowing, and reaping is left to others and even eternity and God. 

By itself, this willingness to postpone the harvest stretches the concept of cause all out of shape. The church is not one more cause on parity with others. Instead, it is the house and people of the Lord, a place and vocation for the people of Grid. But, it is always sowing, seldom reaping; always building, never done. One has to get used to thinking about it in its own terms, otherwise one is invariably thinking wrongly about it.[10]

You remember that when the 70 returned to Jesus with joy because they had achieved results in his name, he quickly corrected their distorted view. He said, “Don’t rejoice about this, but rather because your names are written in heaven—because you are in a new relationship.”

Now, of course, this new relationship will provide the motive for action and behavior appropriate to the new status. But the church is not a community that can be judged sick or healthy merely on the same terms as any other cause.

There is a fourth way of responding to the sickness of the church. If the church is sick, don’t despair, for the characteristic mode of the church’s existence is death and resurrection.[11]

Judaism was completed with the coming of Christianity. The old had to die that the new could live. The body of Jesus had to die that the spirit of Christ could live everywhere. Medieval Romanism was dying and the Reformed church grew out of it in new life. In our day we see evidence of dying taking place and newness of life coming forth. William A. Visser ’t Hooft has written, “Again and again the Church needs to be protected against the downward pull of its own life by which it becomes an end in itself and ceases to be the obedient servant of its Lord.”[12]

This view claims that the church as the body of Christ is called upon to suffer the same fate as the physical body of its Lord.

It cannot be the aim of the church (says John Cantelon) to increase its community, its prestige or influence in the world; it must be the aim of the church to be obedient. God may increase the size of the church, or he may decrease it. In any case the church must live by the evangelical law that he who would save his life will lose it and he who loses his life for the sake of Christ will find it. This means that the church as well as the individual Christian, must expect to find renewal only when it learns to give life for the life of the world.[13]

Just as the church, at the very heart of its worship, is celebrating the death and resurrection of Christ, so the church at the very heart of its work, is practicing death and resurrection in obedience to its Lord. If the church seems to be on the verge of a nervous breakdown, then maybe it is because something We are holding on to needs to die. Perhaps a shakedown is in order. Perhaps one of the root causes is “the theological failure of the church to provide a Christian dynamic at the lay level.” Where are the Keith Millers in our congregations? Is anyone out there in the pews getting “the taste of new wine”? Or are they serving on too many committees, planning too many programs, attending too many meetings, spending too much time keeping the wheels of the machinery moving? These are the questions raised legitimately by the fourth group of respondents. The rhythm of death and resurrection—this is the cycle of all life, the pattern of existence of all organic bodies, the very meaning of the church.

The point being made here is that no one has a cornel’ on the truth. There is a kernel of truth in each of the four answers we’ve considered. We need the comprehensiveness of Christ who “saved what was valuable in what he destroyed and destroyed nothing where it was desirable rather to fulfill than to destroy.”[14] He was forever pulling surprises on those disciples who thought they had things figured out, who thought they knew the kind of kingdom he was building. I was talking with a pastor several weeks ago who said that he was the only “evangelical” in his town’s ministerium. The others won’t associate because they don’t approve of what the so-called liberals are doing.

The reason people hold opposing views and beliefs is not so much that truth is absolute, but that truth takes different forms there is ideal truth and then there is actual or empirical truth. Also, truth has a certain incomprehensibility about it—a quality of infinity. Can any man presume to think that his finite mind comprehends the infinity of God’s truth? Then, too, persons themselves have different temperaments, tastes, interests, and impulses which cause opposing views. Also, language is restrictive. It can only show one side of truth, by a figure or image. It cannot convey any truth whole or by literal embodiment. These are all important reasons why we have differing views of spiritual truth.[15]

If we can agree that no one has all the truth, the important question, it seems to me, is: Are we seeking to know the truth lodged in these opposing views? The comprehensive spirit ascends to a higher position and encompasses whatever truth makes the extremes sacred to their proponents.

Paul’s prayer for the Ephesians was that Christ should dwell in their hearts and that they should be so rooted in love that they would have the power to comprehend that Greek word means to grasp, seize, take hold of with all the people of God the breadth and length and height and depth of that love.

I said that the writer’s argument was that the Christian community was in danger of drifting away from Christ. This brings us to the correctives which the writer to the Hebrews offered. Observe that he didn’t have just one simple antidote. He told those second generation Christians, who had drifted into religious formalism, that they needed to rediscover religion—or better yet—rediscover God for themselves. Religious forms, he said, don’t have a hold over you. It seems to me, that at the heart of it, this is precisely what the Christian radicals are saying. Those in the conservative-evangelical tradition, I think, haven’t taken the radicals seriously enough. They tend to write them off, saying, after all, anyone who would advocate that “God is dead” can’t have anything to offer. But have we tried to see what they mean? We do need to break with certain accumulated trappings of religion. God does need to be interpreted in the thought patterns and language forms of the contemporary generation. God himself doesn’t change, but our concepts of him, and of the ways He works, do. And :if this interpretation is done seriously and authentically, Christians may find themselves staying more securely on due course.

The writer to the Hebrews told those Christians in the second place that their overfamiliarity with religious facts could be corrected by re-exploring the wonders of their faith. He tried to show them the romance of doctrine. He described Jesus as the Brightness of God’s glory and the express image of his person. The emphasis of Christian evangelicals on supernaturalism is a needed one. The secular Christians need to re-explore the exciting aspects of Bethlehem, calvary, and the rolled-away stone and their supernatural meanings if their emphasis is going to remain balanced. But if the Christian radical takes his here-and-now too seriously, I think the fundamentalist takes his doctrinal fundamentals too seriously at the expense of the here-and-now.

For example, I think it’s possible to oversimplify by saying, as Halverson does, that sin is the root of all the social ills and the world’s problems. But remember that Jesus said of the blind man, “Neither hath this man sinned, nor his parents: but that the works of God should be made manifest in him.”

The third cause of drifting—persecution and disillusionment—the writer says may be corrected by exercising patience and faith, believing that God is at work after all. This is the word of the Christian idealists in our day. The church, engaged in a time of sowing, is a different kind of community. When a pastor gets discouraged with results and is persecuted with an identity crisis, when parishioners wonder whether all their efforts are worth it, they need to remember that the church isn’t just another cause. It is God at work.

The fourth cause of drifting away—complacency—must be answered, says the writer, with an admonition to spiritual growth and maturity. There isn’t any such thing as a “finished” Christian. Knowing Christ is not knowledge of a static kind. Here I see a correlation with the truth that the Christian renewalists offer. They are saying that a fuller development necessarily involves renewal—renewal by the process of continuing death and resurrection.

The responses to the condition of the church are varied, The writer to the Hebrews offered several which find their parallel in our day. I ask in closing, Are our eyes open to seeing truth where we’re not accustomed to seeing truth? Are our ears tuned to hearing truth when there is no instinct for hearing truth from that direction?

Leaving the times and the seasons to God, looking beyond ourselves and our own religious and provincial boundaries, let us enlarge the freedom of our faith and the comprehensiveness of our spirit, becoming full-grown men, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ.

Notes

  1. Leon Sutch, “Essay on the Church,” Reflections: A Journal of Opinion at Yale Divinity School, 66 (January, 1969), 5.
  2. J. A. T. Robinson, Honest To God (Philadelphia, 1963).
  3. Harvey Cox, The Secular City (New York, 1965), p. 4.
  4. Joseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics: The New Morality (Philadelphia, 1966), back cover.
  5. Robert Jenson, A Religion Against Itself (Richmond, 1967), pp. 13-14.
  6. Sutch, p. 5.
  7. Richard Halverson, Relevances: The Role of Christianity in the Twentieth Century (Waco, Texas, 1968), pp. 85, 46, 22–23.
  8. See Paul Holmer, “On Criticizing the Church,” Reflection, 66 (January, 1969).
  9. Ibid., p. 3.
  10. Ibid.
  11. John Cantelon, A Protestant Approach to the Campus Ministry (Philadelphia, 1964), p. 109.
  12. Quoted in Cantelon, p. 109.
  13. Ibid., p. 110.
  14. Horace Bashnell, “Christian Comprehensiveness,” in H. Shelton Smith (eel.), Horace Bushnell (New York, 1965), p. 109. This article by Bushnell supplied much of the impetus for the present discussion.
  15. See Bushnell, pp. 110 ff.

A Study of Luke 14:26: Jesus Calls His Disciples to A Life of Supreme Commitment

by Louis F. Gough

“If any one comes to me 
and does not hate his own father and mother and wife
and children and brothers and sisters
and even his own life.
He is not able to be my disciple.”
—(Luke 14:26)

Just what is Jesus saying here? On the surface he seems to be requiring men who would be disciples to despise relatives closest to them as a price to be paid for the privilege of discipleship. But the injunction, understood in this way, is out of character with Jesus and all that he taught as recorded in the gospels and with other sacred literature of both the Old and New Testaments.

Could he who took children in his arms and blessed them command fathers to hate their own sons and daughters? He also had shown tenderness and respect for children in saying that for one to enter the kingdom of God, he must be “converted and become as little children” (Matt. 18:3). On another occasion Jesus had said: “Suffer little children to come to me and forbid them not, for of such is the kingdom of God” (Luke 18:16).

It is also difficult to understand how Jesus could ask men to hate their wives and at the same time inspire Paul to write in the Ephesian Letter: “Husbands, love your wives as Christ also loved the church and gave himself for it” (5:25). In fact if Christ demanded of his followers that they hate, or detest, their wives, would he not be contradicting the basic principle of marital relations as divinely ordained in the beginning of the human race and as upheld by himself in his public ministry? “Male and female made he them. For this cause shall a man leave his father and mother and shall cleave to his wife; and the two shall become one flesh… What therefore God has joined together, let not man put asunder” (Mark 10:6–9).

If we are to connote detestation and feelings of extreme enmity towards others with the word “hate” as used by Jesus, do we not face extreme difficulty with his teachings as recorded in Matthew’s Gospel? “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall love your neighbor, and hate your enemy.’ But I say to you, ‘Love you your enemies and pray for those who persecute you’ “ (Matt. 5:42–43). And how shall we harmonize the injunction “to hate” with a statement which is representative of the ethic of love as taught in the whole Bible and as given by an inspired disciple of Jesus? “Every one who hates his brother is a murderer; and you know that no murderer has eternal life abiding in him” (I John 3:15).

Two final questions which might be raised at the surface of our text: Is it not true that to hate one’s father and mother is to break the Fifth Commandment? And to “hate” one’s “own life,” is that not transgressing the second Great Commandment “You shall love your neighbor as yourself” (Mat. 22:39)?

In light of the whole body of Jesus’ teachings the contradictions implied by these questions are not in keeping with his unity of thought and action displayed throughout the New Testament. An absolute absence of disunity is evident in all of his actions and words when correctly interpreted and understood. A key to understanding Jesus’ words may be here: As true of all great teachers, particularly of the Orient, Jesus did not intend that all of his teachings should be taken literally. One of the methods which he used was of the sort that his words would tend to seize the attention of his hearers and lead them into a search for the deep and rich meaning which was to be found below the surface-meaning.

Jesus often stated a principle in a startling way in the use of a paradox or other figures of speech, leaving it up to his hearers to learn just what he was actually meaning to say. In commenting upon the words of our text, Alfred Plummer and Norval Geldenhuys speak of the startling effect that Jesus’ use of the word “hate” had upon his audience, and the effective learning process that was initiated. Geldenhuys in The New International Commentary on the New Testament observes: “Here Jesus, as he often did, utters the principle in a startling, categorical manner that leaves it to his hearers to find out in the light of His other pronouncements what the qualifications are to which His utterance is subordinated.”[1] Perhaps Jesus utilized such a method as reported in our text. George Buttrick believes that Jesus executed the method excellently: “And hate not: the word repels. It is a staggering word. But then it was intended to be.”[2] To be sure Jesus’ words stagger us. But did he intend for his healers to take them literally? Or did he allow for a figurative or idiomatic interpretation of his word in this text? Just what did he mean? And if the word “hate” should be qualified in the light of all his teachings and in other divine pronouncements found in Holy Scripture, what are those qualifications, and how should the whole text be interpreted?

First, let us look at the word “to hate” as it is used in the Biblical Literature. The Greek verb misein is used by Luke in our text. In most contexts it is translated accurately by the English verb “to hate” with the connotation “to detest,” “to feel extreme enmity toward.” The Hebrew word sane’ and the Aramaic sena’, the equivalents of misein are usually accurately translated by the English verb “to hate:” However, there are contexts in which the Hebrew verb is more accurately translated “to love a person less in comparison to another person.” In Genesis 29:30–31 we read: “And he (Jacob) went in also unto Rachel, and he loved (wayye’ ehabd) also Rachel more than Leah …. And Yahweh saw that Leah was hated, (senu’ah) and he opened her womb.” It is evident here in light of the larger context covering the whole story of the lives of Jacob and his wives that he did not detest or feel strong enmity toward Leah; but more correctly, in comparison his love for Rachel was greater than it was for Leah. Rachel was his favorite wife. The implication that Leah was loved less in verse 30 is translated “hated” (senu’ah) in our English Bibles at verse 31. It is evident the verb in this latter instance should be translated idiomatically “loved less than.” A similar use of the idiom is used in Deuteronomy 21:15, where two wives are referred to as one loved and the other hated, which might be translated: “one favorite,” and the other “second fiddle.” The context goes on to relate that if the second-rate life bears the first child, he should have first-born inheritance rights in spite of the father’s attitude towards his wives.

In Malachi 1:2, 3 we have another instance of this idiom : “I loved (wa’ohabd) Jacob; but Esau I hated (sane’thi). It is not that God detested Esau and felt extreme enmity towards him. Rather, because Esau “despised, (felt contempt, or disregarded) (bazah) for his birthright” (Gen. 25:34), God turned to Jacob, who responded to the call of God to be a channel through whom God’s holy purpose for his people could be realized.

Furthermore, whenever the Greek verb misein in the LXX is used to translate the Hebrew verb sane’ in a context which calls for the idiom, misein should not be translated in the English “to hate” with the connotation to detest or to feel extreme enmity toward. For this reason Abbot-Smith in A Manual Greek Lexicon of the New Testament, 3rd edition, gives the definitions for misein: “to hate, (sometimes with modified sense of indifference or relative disregard for one thing in comparison to another—cf. Matt. 6:24; Luke 14:26; 16:13; John 12:25; Romans 9:13 (LXX).” Frederic Godet also accepts the latter, idiomatic definition: “The word hate in this passage (Luke 14:26) is often interpreted in the sense of loving less.”[3]

J. A. Findlay in his commentary on Luke (The Abingdon Bible Commentary) is of the opinion that “the hate of verse 26 (Lk. 14) goes back to an Aramaic word which means ‘love less’ so that Matthew 10:37, 38 is an accurate rendering of the meaning, if not of the actual words of Jesus” (ad loc).

That Aramaic word, as referred to earlier in this study very possibly is sena’. Let us now look at this parallel passage in Matthew to observe how the First Evangelist reports the words of Jesus.

Matthew in his gospel at 10:37 reports the words of Jesus in parallel with those given in Luke’s gospel as follows: “He who loves father or mother more than Me is not worthy of Me; and he who loves son or daughter more than Me is not worthy of Me” (N.A.S.B.: N.T.) The Greek text reads : “Ho philon patera e metera huper eme ouk estin mou axios; kai ho philon huion e thugatera huper eme ouk estin mou axios.” It is possible that the producer of the First Gospel translated the idiomatic Aramaic word which Jesus might have used into clear and simple Greek. Luke also could have executed his translation as validly but in a different manner, retaining the literary style very similar to the original. Since the Greek verb misein is capable of a double meaning (with the more harsh and quite obscure connotations as is the case with the Hebrew verb sane’ and the Aramaic verb sena’, Luke could have correctly employed misein and thereby preserved the paradox, which no doubt attended Jesus original speech. Thereby the striking force of the Master Teacher’s style would be transmitted through the translation. H. K. Luce in his commentary on the Gospel of Luke characterized the rendering in the Third Gospel as “Luke’s harsher version.[4] Luce is probably correct in observing that it is “no doubt more original” than the rendering in the First Gospel. A. R. C. Leaney is of the opinion that Luke has preserved in 14:26 “what seems to be the more original form of a saying which Matthew has adapted to a later time at 10:37.”[5]

Since, however, a double meaning for the word “hate” in the English language is not used as it is in the case of the Biblical languages, the not-so-rich but more-easily-understood rendering of the original word of Jesus might best be given in a clear, and if necessary diffuse translation, in the English versions. A loss in richness and forcefulness of style is thereby sustained, but that is often the price that is paid for the otherwise convenience of a translation out of the original literature. Kenneth N. Taylor in The Living Gospels has followed this method with the translation: “… must love Me far more than he does his own father…” (Luke 14:26b). The Berkeley Version of the New Testament has it: “… without prizing far less dearly.” Olaf M. Norlie in his The New Testament: A New Translation had done well in rendering the text in understandable English and at the same time preserving something of the paradox: “… and does not, in comparison, hate ….” In other words, the love which a person has for Jesus, if he wishes to be his disciple, must be so much greater than his love for the ones dearest to him, that by comparison the difference in intensity of love would be as great as that which exists between opposites—between love and hate.

Finally, now that we have arrived at an understanding of the word “hate,” what was Jesus saying as he is reported in Luke 14:26? Jesus was on his way to Jerusalem. He had “set his face stedfastly” in that direction, knowing full well what would befall him there. Crucifixion awaited him. In his spirit he had already assumed the cross upon which he would be hung by “his own” whom he loved and whom he had come into the world to save. There were others of “his own” who would follow him to Jerusalem. They had left all to follow him. Jesus loved them; and knowing that he would have to depart from them “he loved them to the fullest measure.” Jesus also knew that his disciples would go through an ordeal in Jerusalem that would try their very souls. It would be a cross for them—not to be equated with his cross, because the sins and burdens of the whole world would be put upon him. But the cross which the disciples would have to bear in Jerusalem while their beloved Master would be rejected and killed ignominiously would be next to more than they could bear. And this would only be the beginning of the crosses which they would be called on to bear down through life as they ventured to follow the Son of God, who was also “the Lamb of God slain from the foundation of the world.” Being aware of the extreme demands which following him would place upon his disciples, and knowing that only total commitment in a life of full and complete submission to his will would enable his disciples to persevere faithfully, Jesus called for undivided allegiance on their part.

This meant that all other allegiances and affections must be subordinated to the allegiance and devotion that the disciples would give their one supreme Master and Lord. His will would dominate their wills, even to the extent that should the solicitations of the dearest and closest relative come into conflict with loyalty to his Master, the disciple must take the latter course at the cost of separation from the loved one if needs be. He might be called upon to give up his very life in the pursuance of the Master’s will for him.

John C. Ryle explains the words of Jesus similarly: “He meant that those who follow Him must love Him with a deeper love even than their nearest and dearest connections, or their own lives …. If the claims of our relatives and the claims of Christ come into collision, the claims of relatives must give way. We must choose rather to displease those we love most upon earth, than to displease Him who died for us on the cross.”[6] Erich Klostermann in his Das Lukasevangelium sees in this requirement for supreme allegiance a willingness on the part of the disciple to accept martyrdom.[7] George Buttrick recognized in this “instant and unqualified loyalty,” demanded by Jesus “proof of his divine claim.”[8]

For the extreme sacrifice which he called upon his followers to make, Jesus compensated with infinitely greater rewards. “Truly, I say to you, there is no one who has left house or wife or brothers or parents or children, for the sake of the kingdom of God, who shall not receive many times as much at this time, and in the age to come, eternal life” (Luke 18:29f, N.A.S.B.).

A final note in our exploration into the meaning of Luke 14:26: Still another paradox is implicit in Jesus’ demand that a disciple hate father, mother and other kinfolk. Even if we accept “to hate” (misein) in its obscure connotation, “to love less,” we find that when Christ becomes the supreme object of our love, our capacity for love of relatives is increased in direct proportion to the enlargement of our love for Christ. The more we love him, the greater the capacity and the better the quality of our love for others; and at the same time the difference between our “first love” for Christ and that for all others which is subordinate to it, is best likened to the magnitude of difference which obtains between two opposites, such as love and hate. In fact a man who does not first love God “with his whole heart” is very limited in his capacity to love others with a quality which is free from self-interestedness and possessiveness.

George Buttrick gives expression to this paradoxical phenomenon: “Our human loyalties clash, and they become debased unless they are unified and purified by a supreme devotion …. That strange word hate (as it was used by Jesus) is the one road to abiding love.”[9] An eighteenth-century prayer of Bishop Joseph Butler quoted by Buttrick certainly is to the point: “Help us, by the due exercise of them (our affections), to improve to Perfection; till all partial affection be lost in that entire universal one, and Thou, O God, shalt be all in all.”[10]

Notes

  1. Norval Geldenhuys, Commentary on the Gospel of Luke, The New International Commentary on the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 1954), ad loc.
  2. George Arthur Buttrick, The Gospel According to St. Luke; Exposition Chapters 13–18, Vol. 8 of The Interpreter’s Bible (12 Vol.: New York: Abingdon Press, 1952), ad loc.
  3. Frederick Godet, A Commentary on the Gospel of St. Luke, trans, by M. D. Cusin (Clark’s Foreign Theological Library, 4th Series, Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1875), ad loc.
  4. H. K. Luce, The Gospel According to St. Luke (Cambridge Greek Testament, Cambridge: Univ. Press, 1933), ad loc.
  5. A. R. C. Leaney, A Commentary on the Gospel According to St. Luke (London: Adam and Clarles Black, (c. 1958). ad loc.
  6. John Charles Ryle, Expository Thoughts on the Gospels far Family and Private Use; St. Luke, ninth ed. (London: William Hunt & Co., 1890), ad loc.
  7. Erich Klostermann, Das Lukasevangelium, Band II.l of Handbuch zum Neuen Testament (Tubingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 1919), ad loc.
  8. Buttrick, Ibid.
  9. Ibid.
  10. Ibid.

Thursday, 1 April 2021

Some Classic Views of the Church

by Owen H. Alderfer

To those who have devoted time to thought and study about the nature of the church it is readily evident that a number of views have developed and persisted over the years. While giving specific attention to the Brethren views of the church in this issue of the Bulletin, it seems appropriate that other views be indicated which have existed over long periods of time in widespread movements.

The concern of this study is the essential nature of the church—the church as the church. One’s view of what the church is will, indeed, affect his view of everything to which the church is related. If we can discover some “classic views” of the church, it is assumed that it can readily be seen how the various views will work out in the respective relationships.

The approach to this study is historical and theological: It will attempt to locate in time views of the church that have lasted across the years and have influenced the church in various geographic sections or theological streams. The study will attempt, furthermore, to trace out the thought of the several views, suggesting directions in which the respective views may lead insofar as the church in its relationships is concerned. The study takes up classic views beginning with the most ancient views, the Eastern and the Western, leading to the Eastern Orthodox and the Roman Catholic. From there the study moves to two Protestant views, the Lutheran and the Reformed.

The Eastern View of the Church: The Mystical View

By “Eastern view” of the church this study refers to a general attitude which grew up in Christianity east of the Adriatic, in Greek speaking parts of Christianity during the first seven Christian centuries. It is not easy to delineate a specific “Eastern view” of the church because of the mood characteristic of the developing church in that part of Christianity. This attitude did not lend itself of official systematization and legal codes which defined the church and governed its development. The Eastern church is characterized more by a spirit than any clear abiding formulation of a doctrine of the church. Still, it is appropriate to try to grasp that spirit as it indicates a view of the church.

In the early centuries of Christianity, characterizing features began to develop within the church in the eastern Mediterranian which set it apart from the church in the West. The East, productive of a host of great Christian thinkers and writers, walked in the spirit of the Greek heritage to which it was indebted. The speculation of the philosopher, the mystical quality of Platonism, the imagery of the poet and dramatist, the individualism of the early democracy united with a trust in persons more than in laws—all these contributed to the attitude of Christian writers of the East. Eastern names—Origen, Athanasius, the Cappadocian Fathers, Cyril of Alexandra, and Eusebius of Caesarea, to name a few—are associated with the metaphysical speculation which led to the profound theological issues coming to focus in the ecumenical councils.

Preoccupation with the Logos, often interpreted in Neoplatonic modes, and concern with salvation emphasizing immortality became the central themes of Eastern thought. Athanasius’ writing summarizes the thinking of the East in these areas in a few sentences in Of the Incarnation:

He was made man that we might be made God and He manifested Himself by a body that we might receive the idea of the unseen Father; and He endured the insolence of men that we might inherit immortality.[1]

Athanasius is saying that the manifesting of the Logos is a fact, but more: it is a lesson, a symbol, a sacrament. Christ is seen as being born in us, dwelling in us, permeating us with spiritual life. To such concerns the Eastern church devoted its attention; it endeavored to fathom the mysteries of the world above. The practical focus of the church—if practical it may be called—came to be the realization and enjoyment of these mysteries in personal experience through reason and liturgy.

To this point the study has dealt with philosophical backgrounds and theological concerns of the Eastern church rather than with an Eastern view of the church. In such a setting, however, and in the absence of an explicated ecclesiology, the Eastern view of the church is to be discovered. M. J. Congar discusses the development of a view of the church in the East and suggests reasons why greater development did not occur:

The thought of Eastern ecclesiology from the first envisages in the mystery of the church that which it encompasses of the divine realities rather than the earthly aspects and the human implications. It focuses upon the inner reality of the unity in faith and love rather than the concrete demands of the ecclesiastical communion. One observes the relatively weak development of the ecclesiology of the Greek Fathers; the truth is that these have dwelt in a large measure upon Christology and even more upon pneumatology. They see the church in Christ and in the Holy Spirit rather than in its ecclesiastical being as such.[2]

Arising from these ideas in Eastern Christianity is what may be called a mystical view of the church. John Oman sees this as “…the idea of the Church as primarily a mysterious hierurgical saving institution.”[3] The church is a means whereby the ideas and experiences of the divine realms—the real world—are communicated to men. Indeed, as the future concerns of the Eastern church would show, there must be concerns for truth—orthodoxy, the law of God, and clerical orders, but these are of value only as they contribute to experiencing the relation to Christ and the attainment of immortality through Him.

Such a view of the church resulted in the development of an extensive liturgy as an aid to the attainment of spiritual reality. Congar in his work After Nine Hundred Years shows that the Eastern church across the years has placed great value on “a line of descent from celestial realities to the midst of the sensible world,” so that there developed “a rather sumptuous liturgy, imbued with Holy Mysteries and the idea of ‘Heaven on Earth.’ It was a church essentially sacramental, a church of prayer with less attention to the exigencies of its militant and its itinerant state.”[4]

Father Congar has implied some of the results which tend to flow from a mystical view of the church: Elaborate liturgy developed, the incarnating of divine ideas to raise men’s minds to God. The life of devotion, including the elevation of asceticism, found stress. Individualism expressed within the framework of the church resulted, minimizing the role of corporate worship. The same mood carried over into the structures of the church: priestly and episcopal organization never attained an established unity for the whole church. The church developed into a number of communities belonging to various states. Out of this situation, in many cases, the church became subordinated to the state.

From this brief study of the Eastern church, it may be generalized that a mystical view of the church tends toward a focus upon divine realities. It stresses personal experience of the divine provisions in opening to the individual various degrees of depth in realization. It lends itself to individualism—concern for personal experience unrelated to other persons. It holds the danger of unrelatedness to the present world.

The Western View Of The Church: The Hierarchial View

As described above, the eastern part of the church developed its own peculiar thought and patterns leading to the structure known as the Eastern Orthodox branch of Christendom. So also, the western part of the church developed according to its thought and patterns into the Roman Catholic branch of Christendom, greatly influencing subsequent developments in all Western Christianity. Because this is a part of our more immediate heritage than the Eastern, this story is a more familiar one to us.

The Western view of the church is more easily traced out than the Eastern because a progression of Western Fathers wrote explicitly on the nature of the church. Here theological and practical overtones are present; as the vision of the church developed—often out of a current controversy—new statements were presented to clarify and crystallize thinking on the church. Later writers built upon their predecessors; sometimes they invested the earlier writings with new meanings. Ideas from several of the Western Fathers should be noted to show progress in thought concerning the church.

Irenaeus (died c. 200) gathers up the main second century ideas of the church and presents an outline of developing views. In Against Heresies he wrote, “Where the Church is, there is the Spirit of God; and where the Spirit of God is, there is the Church and all grace; …”[5] The church is the sole repository of truth; this is the case because it holds the apostolic faith and the apostolic writings. In a passage later to be much used and abused, he illustrated his case by the Roman church, the church founded by Peter and Paul. It represents Christendom in miniature.[6] Others, such as Tertullian (died c. 220), reflect similar ideas, stressing the soleness of the church and the deposit of faith guaranteed by an unbroken succession of bishops.

In Cyprian of Carthage (died 258) the Western view of the church advances notably. Writing at the time of the Novationist schism Cyprian stressed the unity of the church and noted that this was a unity maintained through the bishops who stand in the place of the apostles.[7] The church is founded on the bishops of which Peter is the first; it is “united and held together by the glue of the mutual cohesion of the bishops.”[8] Reasoning from here he argues that one “cannot have God for his father who has not the Church for his mother.” There is no salvation outside the church represented by the bishops in proper succession; furthermore, rebellion against the bishop is rebellion against God.[9] Here is a practical legal approach to the doctrine of the church. Clearly inherent in Cyprian’s doctrine is much that will harden into medievel and later Catholic views of the church.

The Western church is indebted more to St. Augustine of Hippo (died 430) than to any other single person for the development of its doctrine of the church. Forced to deal with these issues by the Donatist controversy, Augustine wrote extensively on the nature of the church. He accepted the teachings relative to the church current in his time: the church is the bride of Christ, the mother of Christians; there is no salvation apart from it; the church is equated with the universal Catholic Church with its hierarchy and sacraments, and its center is at Rome. Augustine’s unique contributions are in three areas: (1) His view of the mystical relationship of the church to Christ—the body to the Head. (2) His conception that the church’s unity follows logically as a fellowship of love; schism, therefore, is sacrilege, the rending of the church by lack of charity. (3) His distinction between the essential church composed of those who genuinely belong to Christ and the outward empirical church which includes sinners—the distinction between the church visible and the church invisible.[10]

In a definitive work on early historical theology, J. N. D. Kelly observes that, “By the middle of the fifth century the Roman Church had established de jure as well as de facto, a position of primacy in the West, and the papal claims to supremacy over all bishops of Christendom had been formulated in precise terms.”[11] Upon this framework of a hierarchical view of the church was constructed the great institution that dominated the West in the Middle Ages. That is the story of the working out of these ideas in practice which shows the genius of the Western view of the church. If the Eastern church tended to be mystical the Western church tended to be practical, activist, and pragmatic. As Congar summarizes, “This was a church much more effectively marked by the system of militant action and the human expression of the spiritual-celestial authority…”[12]

While a final pronouncement on the Roman Catholic dogma of the church is yet to be made, the practical outworking of this hierarchial view has long since been in operation. The church is microcosmically present in the Pope, the head of the church on earth. Through him spiritual authority is passed to the lesser orders which are in proper succession. In him the purity of faith is assured, the validity of the sacraments guaranteed, and the Christian legal system established. Vatican I (1870) placed the capstone on the system in its declaration of Papal Infallibility, a device for both securing and manipulating tradition. As explicated in the Council of Trent (1545–1563) the church has instituted rites of aid to man’s salvation. She reserves the right to interpret Scripture and to determine accepted versions. She is the one church declaring and assuring the validity of the sacraments; their power is vested in the church. Thus, the church is the only agent of salvation.

The hierarchical view of the church leads to a very efficient organization and institution. It maintains organic unity allowing for a measure of diversity but defining the boundaries of divergence to be tolerated. In this view the power of the church rests in the hands of the few; the many are often little more than passive spectators accepting the assurance of salvation promised by ecclesiastical leaders. Purity and effectiveness in such a view depends upon the quality and ability of the leadership.

The Lutheran View: A Dualistic View

Sometimes positions are more easily described than named; this is true of Luther’s view of the church.[13] The term “Dualistic View” is adopted to suggest Luther’s view of the church as internal and outward, as hidden and seen, as a spiritual fellowship and an organized association, as above the world and part of the world, as saved and sinner. Luther’s dualism arose out of a dilemma: he wanted both a believer’s church based on personal faith and experience and a territorial church which included all in a given locality.[14] In trying to preserve something of both he settled for a compromise.

As did much of Luther’s thought, his view of the church began with his emphasis upon justification by faith. As an Augustinian, however, Luther believed that faith is a gift of God based upon election. The church, therefore, cannot be all inclusive. He insisted that the church is made up of those who live in true faith, hope and love; “… the essence, life and nature of the church is not a bodily assembly, but an assembly of hearts in one faith, …”[15] Moreover, Luther saw that the church is one, not because of any relation to a center like Rome, but because “… each one preaches, believes, hopes, loves, and lives like the other.”[16] A spiritual unity makes a church. Further, Luther’s view of the sacraments brought him to the belief that only convinced believers in true relationship with God and fellowship with the church should share in the Lord’s supper, for only where faith is present are the sacraments efficacious.

Such views imply both a spiritualistic approach to the church and a high degree of individualism. Realizing dangers in these tendencies Luther emphasized ideas which modified the positions and held them in tension with balancing views. He was forced to this from two directions: the necessity of establishing an evangelical church order over against the Catholics and the urgency of setting forth a defense against the theories of the Anabaptists of the type of Muntzer.[17] In providing these answers he moved in the direction of a territorial church.

In the matter of establishing an evangelical church order Luther had to consider a form to be assumed by the external church that it might be an appropriate agency for the production of the communion of saints. Here Luther insisted that only the Word and the sacraments are necessary for the existence of the church; the hierarchy and the Roman See are not essential. The role of the Word and the sacraments was not to be minimized in any way, however. To him these were the marks which made the “bodily external Christendom (Christenheit)” evident. To this outer church belong leaders and laity whether truly Christian or not. “The external marks, whereby one can perceive where this church is on earth, are baptism, the Sacrament (Lord’ Supper), and the Gospel.”[18] These were more than ornaments of the church; indeed, they were seen as effective in bringing people to God. He wrote, “Where baptism and the gospel are, there let no one doubt that there are also saints, even though it should be only children in their cradles.” The outward bodily church and the inner spiritual church are to be carefully discriminated, but not separated. They are related to one another as body and soul in man.[19]

Luther’s view of the church worked out in a kind of dualism in many areas of theology and experience. In anthropology he saw justified man as yet sinner. The man of Romans, chapter seven, was for Luther the justified man struggling—not very successfully—against sin in the flesh. Following through on this view into society-at-large Luther saw the need for the authority and power of the state to keep men in line—even in a Christian state. He saw little prospect of the coming of a Christian society. A man was a citizen of two communities, the church and the state. Each had its function. It was good to have Christian princes governing the state, but the state was hereby not more Christian, even though in such a state the church could play its role more fully.

Luther’s dualism tended toward polarization in many areas of theology and practice rather than balance and tension. In seeking to retain opposites rather than finding a synthesis or a balance, a potentially unstable situation obtains. History showed that people tend either to bog down into an unconcerned indifference in the face of apparently irreconcilable tenets; or, having a vital concern in the life and thinking of the church, they tend to move toward one pole or the other creating divisions.

The Calvinistic View: A Theocratic View

While the term “Theocratic” generally has application to a dominant role of a church or a priestly class in the state, for want of a better, this term is applied here to Calvin’s view of the church. This is justified in the light of Calvin’s emphasis upon divine sovereignty and his view of the application of that sovereignty within every aspect of the church and extending [beyond into society. Calvin’s idea of the church was seasoned by a dream of the Holy Commonwealth in the terrestrial sphere.

John Calvin, who was among the latest of the great Reformation writers, borrowed freely from earlier reformers in developing his view of the church.[20] His view of the Lord’s Supper as a channel of spiritual communion was similar to that of Luther. The concept of the Holy Commonwealth along with that of limited use of external aids in worship showed affinities to Zwingli. The idea of the church as a community of convinced believers and the demand for rigorous discipline suggested Anabaptist influence. However, Calvin adapted these elements to his own thinking and in light of the idea of divine sovereignty developed them into a view of the church that was his own.

For Calvin, influenced by Augustine, the church was constituted of all the elect—the dead, the living, and the unborn,[21] though it is not clear to man in every case who is a true member of the church. “Church” as used in the Scriptures frequently designated the whole multitude dispersed over all the world, professing faith in Jesus Christ, initiated into his faith by baptism, testifying to their unity in doctrine and communion, and consenting to the Word. Many in the church, however, are not of it, for there are here hypocrites of various sorts. This makes necessary a differentiation between the church visible and the church invisible: the tares ever grow along with the wheat.[22] Calvin stated, “We ought to acknowledge as members of the church all those who by a confession of faith, an exemplary life, and a participation of the sacraments, profess the same God and Christ with ourselves.”[23]

The true, invisible church, being based on election, is known but to God. Calvin found the doctrine of election—trust in absolute divine sovereignty in relation to individual salvation—a doctrine of comfort. He was willing to leave such matters to God. It was not man’s business to be preoccupied with his salvation, to seek assurance, or to earn his salvation; man’s vocation was to honor God.[24] Calvin was willing to outline these matters as he saw them in the Scriptures. The outworking he left to God while he turned the greater part of his attention to the structure and activity and expression of the visible church.

According to Calvin the church of God exists “wherever we find the word of God purely preached and heard and the sacraments administered according to the institution of Christ.”[25] It is necessary for persons to be related to the church, for God considers “every one as a traitor and apostate from religion, who perversely withdraws himself from any Christian society which preserves the true ministry of the word and sacraments… Separation from the church is the denial of God and Christ.”[26] With the church is vested the power of the keys, the power of granting forgiveness and the ministry of reconciliation,[27] a power associated with the preaching of the Gospe1.[28] For these reasons Calvin was concerned that the entire community be involved in the church and that the church be involved in the entire community.

Calvin was explicit that the state should be distinct from the church. Only the state had power to wield the sword and to administer physical punishment against evil doers—even if they were a part of the church. However, within the church itself there must be discipline. Believers should be admonished regarding their errors; those who led scandalous lives should be removed from the church. The wicked should be separated from the righteous that they may not be an evil influence and that the erring may be led to repentance.[29] Such correction should not be administered by one person, but by a lawful assembly.[30]

In actual practice, first in Geneva, and later in Scotland and New England, the Reformed Church shaped after Calvin’s thought became an agency which enforced the will of the church on the whole community. In these Calvinistic centers where the church was able to dominate the situation, life and morality were prescribed by the church. To have significant voice in the community one must be a part of the church, subscribing to its principles and practices. The structure of the church with the eldership serving as a kind of spy system to root out evil and divergency assured an oligarchy of the elect. The magistrates became the servants of the church to provide and enforce laws which would secure spiritual and material prosperity and to punish every uprising against the recognized religion.[31] The consistory, under the guidance of the clergy, elders, and deacons, became the voice of God to the community guiding its affairs, establishing a theocracy in fact. Such a Holy Commonwealth could be realized only as there was high selectivity of membership. Disidents had to line up or leave.

A theocratic view of the church carries advantages for the church in its handling of competition. The church directly or indirectly controls manners and morals through discipline in the church, legislation in society-at-large, and elimination of the opposition in general. It makes for a rigorous and demanding church, both in itself and in the community—at least in the first stages of the theocracy and for as long as the vision persists with clarity. The church is all-encompassing; all facets of life come under its domination. Church and community are essentially one.

Problems arise from this view in that religion is practically forced upon people. While ideally all are church members voluntarily, in fact, many are members and participate in the church under pressure and for expediency. In succeeding generations problems become particularly apparent as those born into the families of the godly fail to share in the vision of their parents. More than some others this approach contributes to hypocrisy within the church because there is so much to be gained in maintaining an appearance of godliness.

Reflections and Conclusions

From the views of the church surveyed in this study several statements may be offered as reflections suggesting conclusions:

  1. Theology is fundamental to ecclesiology. The way in which a group understands God and his ways with men will have considerable bearing upon the view of the church which it develops. Any religious body must keep its theology in view as it attempts to clarify its ecclesiology.
  2. Ecclesiology determines polity within a religious body; indeed, polity is the means for interpreting and applying the view of the church.
  3. Out of ecclesiology flows the “style of life” and the general direction of religious thought and expression of the members of a religious body. A shift in ecclesiology will precede shifts in the “style of life” and the general direction of expression of the members of a group and vice versa.

In conclusion, it may be said that a clear understanding and explication of the doctrine of the church is crucial to a logical development and an effective expression of any religious body. A grasp of the nature of the church by its members is a key to any intelligent witness to the world.

Notes

  1. Athanasius, Of the Incarnation, in Johannes Quasten, Patrology (Westminster, Md.: The Newman Press, 1963), Vol. III, p. 71.
  2. M. 3. Congar, Chretiens Desunis, Principes d’un “OEcumenisme” Catholique, tr. by the present writer (Paris: Les Editions du Cerf, 1937), p. 14.
  3. John Oman, “The Church,” James Hastings, Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics (N. Y.: Scribners, 1911), III, p. 622.
  4. Yves Congar, After Nine Hundred Years (New York: Ford-ham University Press, 1959), p. 51.
  5. Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 24, 1.
  6. Ibid., III, 3, 2.
  7. Cyprian, The Unity of the Church.
  8. ______Epistle LX VIII, 8.
  9. ______The Unity of the Church and various Epistles, e.g., LIX, 5; LX, 5; LXIX, 1.
  10. J. N. D. Kelly, Early Christian Doctrines (New York: Harper and Brothers 1960), pp. 412-417.
  11. Ibid., p. 417.
  12. Congar, op. cit., p. 52.
  13. It should be stated that this study seeks to present some of Luther’s views of the church rather than elaborate those developed in the Lutheran movement. The same applies in the case of Calvin and the Reformed movement.
  14. Roland Baintan, Here I Stand (New York, Mentor Books, 1950), p. 243.
  15. Martin Luther, “The Papacy at Rome,” Works of Martin Luther, Philadelphia Edition, 6 vols. (Philadelphia: Muhlenburg Press, 1943), I, p. 349.
  16. Ibid.
  17. Reinhold Seeburg, Textbook of the History of Doctrines (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Book House, 1964), II, p. 292.
  18. Luther, op. cit., p. 361
  19. Ibid.
  20. Roland Bainton, The Reformation of the Sixteenth Century (Boston, Mass.: Beacon Press, paperback ed., 13th printing, 1965), p. 110.
  21. John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, IV, i, 7.
  22. Ibid.
  23. Ibid., IV, i, 8.
  24. Ibid., III, xxi, 1–7.
  25. Ibid., IV, i, 9.
  26. Ibid., IV, i, 10.
  27. Ibid., IV, 1, 22.
  28. Ibid., IV, xi, 1.
  29. Ibid., IV, xii, 6.
  30. Ibid., IV, xi, 5.
  31. Seeberg, op. cit., p. 411.

Arminius and Arminianism

by Owen H. Alderfer

Two incidents reported by Geoffrey F. Nuttall, London pastor, in Man’s Faith and Freedom state the case for this article.[1] He reports that an examination required for a higher degree in one of the English universities included, among several alternative questions, the topic, “Since Wesley we are all Arminians.” In the other incident Nuttall reported discussing an Arminian symposium in which he was involved with a knowledgable friend, a man who had authored books on subjects related to Methodism. The friend reported: “Do you know, I never realized that there was anyone called Arminius!”

The incidents say at least two things that bear consideration: First, Arminius and the spirit of Arminianism have had enormous bearing upon Christianity in the English speaking world. Second, this is true of us whether we have ever heard of Arminius or not. And this leads to the concerns of this study: Who was James Arminius and what were some of his central ideas? Beyond this, what is Arminianism and what are its principles and impact?

James Arminius

James Arminius began life in a time of considerable religious significance. When he was born (1560) John Calvin was alive; the Council of Trent was in session; Queen Elizabeth I was bringing about the Anglican Settlement; Menno Simons was leading the Anabaptists; Arminius’ native Holland was bleeding in religious war.

By the time Arminius came into his own his homeland had largely espoused Calvinism. After study at the new Dutch University of Leyden, Arminius studied abroad in Basle and Geneva where he became thoroughly oriented in Calvinistic thinking. Returning home he became popular as a preacher in Amsterdam. When he was called upon to answer attacks upon supralapsarian views of election Arminius questioned the very views he was to defend. Called to a chair of divinity at Leyden he aired views which favored human freedom and questioned the current positions on divine decrees.

From 1603 until his death in 1609 Arminius was engaged in controversy with Calvinistic leaders of the Reformed Church. Feeling that his contemporaries in the ministry and the theological chairs of the universities distorted the Scriptures and the Fathers Arminius sought to present what he thought was the Biblical view of the nature of God, the nature of man, and the way of salvation.

The nature of God. Arminius judged that current views which saw God as decreeing the Fall and the damnation of some men from all eternity made God the author of sin. Irenic in a time when peace-loving attitudes were uncommon, Arminius framed his thought in Calvinistic patterns and differed with his opponents only at points where he felt he must. He held that God ordained to save and damn certain particular persons; however, “The decree has its foundation in the foreknowledge of God, by which he knew from all eternity those individuals who would through his preventing grace, believe, and through his subsequent grace would persevere,…”[2] There are absolute decrees, but these are three and evangelical; viz., (1) “…to appoint his Son…for a Mediator, Redeemer, Savior, Priest, and King who might destroy sin by his own death,…by his obedience…obtain salvation…”; (2) “…to receive into favor those who repent and believe…; but to leave in sin, and under wrath, all impenitent persons …”; (3) “…to administer in a sufficient and efficacious manner the means which were necessary for repentance and faith; …”[3] He asserted, “…As believers alone are saved, so only believers are predestinated to salvation. But the Scriptures know no Election, by which God precisely and absolutely has determined to save any one without having first considered him as a believer.”[4] It must be allowed that the sovereign God permits evil. Indeed, Arminius asserted, “…Even all actions whatever, concerning evil that can possibly be devised or invented, may be attributed to Divine Providence — employing solely one caution, ‘not to conclude from the concession that God is the cause of sin.’”[5]

The nature of man. In dealing with the question of human nature Arminius’ concern was for free will. He insisted upon the Absolute in but one quarter: “I am desirous, that we should…contend FOR THE NECESSITY OF GOD ALONE,. .. and that we should contend for the CONTINGENCY OF ALL OTHER THINGS AND EFFECTS.”[6 ]God is absolute and necessary; He has decreed and provided salvation — but conditionally. When He employs his creatures in the administration of his Providence He “… conducts all things in such a manner that…he does not take away from them their nature, natural properties or the use of them, but allows them to perform and complete their own proper motions.”[7] God’s creatures, including man, are free to be themselves. No less than Calvin, Arminius held that original sin offended God and resulted in punishment. This sin is not peculiar to first man, however; it is common to the entire race so that all are under wrath thereby.[8] The powers of free will “… are not only debilitated and useless unless they be assisted by grace, but [they have] no powers whatever except such as are excited by Divine grace.”[9] “Preventing grace” comes to the rescue so that man is capable of responding to the call of God as he will.[10] Human freedom is hereby genuine. “All unregenerate persons have freedom of will, and a capability of resisting the Holy Spirit, of rejecting the proffered grace of God,…these things they can actually do, without any difference of the elect and of the reprobate.”[11]

Arminius was careful to point out that he was not Pelagian in his views, an error with which he had been charged. He declared that in his own abilities man is helpless; sufficiency of grace must be ascribed to him by the Holy Spirit, “…and such sufficiency may be ascribed…, as to keep at the greatest possible distance from Pelegianism.”[12] Man is fallen, the victim of original sin, but through prevenient grace, even in his state of guilt, he has genuine freedom and the power to resist grace and choose for against God.

Soteriology. Having broken from the logic-tight system of Calvinism at the point of predestination, Arminius likewise rejected a limited atonement. Interestingly, he turned to antiquity, quoting Prosper of Aquitain to indicate and support his view: “‘With respect both to the magnitude and potency of the price, and with respect to the one general cause of mankind, the blood of Christ is the redemption of the whole world.’”[13] Though the atonement is universal in its provisions, not all will share in it. He wrote, “The accidental result of vocation, and that which is not of itself intended by God, is the rejection of the word of grace,…the resistance offered to the Holy Spirit.” The end of this is the judgment of God.[14]

In the soteriological process justification and regeneration are logically and temporally related for Arminius. Sinners are justified — accounted righteous solely by the obedience of Christ, he held, and wrote, “But since God imputes the righteousness of Christ to none except believers, I conclude that… it may be well and properly said, To a man who believes, Faith is imputed for righteousness through grace, …”[15] Regeneration is closely associated with justification. Arminius declared: “…For Christ becomes ours by faith, and we are ingrafted into Christ,…that we may draw from him the vivifying power of the Holy Spirit, …” Justification expresses in a regenerate life in which “…a man…has a mind freed from the darkness and vanity of the world, and illuminated with the true and saving knowledge of Christ,…”[16] Such experience in the life of the believer leads to a clear assurance of salvation, for, “Since God promises eternal life to all who believe in Christ, it is impossible for him who believes, and who knows that he believes, to doubt of his own salvation, …”[17]

Sanctification is the desired end in the living of the Christian life. By grace God purifies man who is a sinner, and yet a believer and leads him in deeper knowledge and purer life. Arminius wrote, “This sanctification is not completed in a single moment; but sin,…is weakened more and more by daily losses, …”[18] Arminius doubted that man can ever in this life be free from tension in this regard as he wrote, “… Man is not fully and perfectly regenerate so long as he is in the present life.” This, however, must be understood, “… as relating not to the essence and essential parts of regeneration itself, but to the degree and measure of the quantity.”[19] Further, Arminius had serious questions about the possibility of anyone keeping the law perfectly; whatever of progress a man makes in this direction must be credited to grace.[20] In spite of these ideas Arminius insisted that justification — though not a result of work — will be productive of good works. “Faith, and faith only, (though there is no faith alone without works,) is imputed for righteousness,” he wrote.[21]

Arminianism

Arminius was a prophetic figure. This is true not so much in the specific views he declared as in the spirit he represented. Irenic, tolerant, and open-minded he was the harbinger of a new climate that was coming to birth in the Western world, a spirit that would find expression in both secular and religious thought.

After Arminius died (1609) friends who followed his thinking drew up a statement of beliefs, “The Remonstrance” of 1610, in hope of bringing about peace in the church. These summarized Arminius’ thought.[22] The statements achieved an end opposite that desired. They became the core of a theological battle that ended with the Synod of Dort, 1618–1619. In this synod a strongly Calvinistic confession was adopted and the Arminians were condemned. Those rejected established a denomination which came to be known as the Remonstrant Brotherhood.[23]

Arminianism, though rejected at first, was shortly to gain acceptance in other places; however, the directions it took and the ideas associated with the movement were often far removed from the views of Arminius himself. Within less than a century the Anglican Church was reflecting Arminian views in the Books of Homilies, though the Thirty-Nine Articles were firmly Calvinistic in tone.[24] Primarily through these homilies Arminian thought was mediated to John Wesley, an ardent champion of Arminian thought.[25] Much the same movement could be traced elsewhere.

While there were those such as Wesley who represented a fairly “pure” Arminian thought, Arminianism in due time came to be associated with ideas far removed from those of Arminius. An enquiring attitude and a conciliatory spirit had been marks of the man; now, enemies of Arminius came to associate every movement of free thinking and irenic disposition with Arminianism. Indeed, some of the Remonstrants did move from earlier positions to heterodox views in Christology and anthropology; however, “Arminian” became a pejorative term which encompassed a host of questionable positions of the Enlightenment period.

An example of this development is seen in the times of Jonathan Edwards. As pastor at Northampton in 1734 he saw in New England a spreading “Arminianism,” by which he meant trust in human ability and a libertarianism which led to self-confidence. His preaching of justification by faith alone and against Arminian principles was a key factor in the revival that led to the Great Awakening in New England.

The climate of opinion was, however, against Edwards and in favor of “Arminianism.” Even by Edwards’ time, for the most part, Arminianism was a prevailing mood. Western man was coming to have confidence in his own abilities. The Arminianism which Edwards feared developed and expanded in the century and one-half after his time. By the twentieth century men had forgotten Arminius, but the spirit and views he represented, as conveyed by those called Arminians, were a part of the mental furniture of the majority of men in the Western world.

Notes

  1. Geoffrey F. Nuttall, “The Influence of Arminianism in England,” in Gerald O. McCulloh, ed., Man’s Faith and Freedom, the Theological Influence of Jacobus Arminius. (New York: Abingdon Press, 1962), p. 46.
  2. Arminius, Declaration of Sentiments, I, 5, in The Writings of James Arminius, 3 vols., tr. by James Nichols and W. R. Bagnall (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1956), Vol. I, p. 250.
  3. Ibid., p. 247.
  4. Arminius, Nine Questions, I; Writings, I, p. 380.
  5. Arminius, Declaration of Sentiments, II; Writings, I, pp. 251, 252.
  6. Arrninius, Against the Thirty-one Articles, VI; Writings, I, pp. 293 ff.
  7. Op. Cit., VII, pp. 296 f.
  8. Arminius, Public Disputations, VII; Writings, I, pp. 485, 486.
  9. Op. Cit., XI; pp. 523, 531.
  10. Arminius, Against the Thirty-One Articles, IV, 1; Writings, I, pp. 287, 288.
  11. Arminius, Certain Articles to be Diligently Examined and Weighed; Writings, II, pp. 496, 497.
  12. Arminius, Against the Thirty-one Articles, VIII; Writings, I, 299–301.
  13. Op. Cit., XII; pp. 316-317.
  14. Arminius, Public Disputations, XVI; Writings, I, pp. 570-574.
  15. Arminius, Declaration of Sentiments, IX; Writings, I, pp. 263, 264.
  16. Arminius, Dissertation on Romans VII; Writings, II, pp. 225- 229.
  17. Arminius, Nine Questions, VII; Writings, I, pp. 384, 385.
  18. Arminius, Private Disputations, XLIX, “On the Sanctification of Man;” Writings, II, pp. 119-121.
  19. Arminius, Dissertation on Romans VII; Writings, II, p. 247.
  20. Arminius, Declaration of Sentiments, VII; Writings, II, pp. 255, 256.
  21. Arminius, Letter to Hippolytus a Collibus, V; Writings, II, p. 473.
  22. Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1919), Vol. III, pp. 545-549.
  23. Lambertus Jacobus van Holk, “From Arminius to Arminianism in Dutch Theology,” in Gerald O. McCulloh, op. cit., pp. 28-29.
  24. See especially Articles X, “Free-Will,” and XVII, “Of Predestination and Election.”
  25. John Wesley, “On God’s Vineyard,” in Sermons on Several Occasions (New York: Waugh and T. Mason, 1836), Vol. II, p. 389. Here Wesley declares his dependence on the Homilies “…in setting their judgment on the grand point of justification by faith,…”

Aspects of Psalm 1

by Bruce C. Stark

Because they reflect the deepest personal experiences of men of all ages, the Psalms are the most widely read and most deeply appreciated of all the Old Testament literature. They possess a peculiar warmth that is not to be found in such generous abundance anywhere else in the canonical Old Testament. There are many ponderous questions in reference to the Psalter which cannot presently be a part of our concern. Theories of the origin and growth of the book are diverse and intricate. Classification schemes are myriad, and none are totally satisfactory.

Psalm 1 offers an interesting object of study for various reasons, including the fact that it comes first. We shall comment on this shortly. The formal analysis of the Psalm is designated by Briggs as two antithetical strophes of six tetrameter lines each.[1] It should be noted, however, that he considers verse three a gloss and does not integrate it into the formal arrangement noted above. The present writer feels no constraint to follow him here.

There is no designated author and no superscription to assist us in reconstructing the historical situation in which the poem was composed. Little help is found in the text either, since the references are rather general. These facts, however, may assist us in our efforts to interpret the psalm, for the very lack of knowledge of a specific historical milieu may properly encourage us to keep the application of the message broad.

Psalm 1 bears close connection contextually with Psalm 2. Some have felt this so strongly that they are willing to believe that they are, in fact, one. In pointing out the striking similarities between these two psalms, Hengstenberg is most helpful, and the reader is referred to his discussion for more elaborate treatment.[2] Briefly, however, we may notice here the facts that Psalm 2 begins with judgment where Psalm 1 ends, and Psalm 1 starts with a benediction parallel to the end of Psalm 2. Also, there is a clear parallel between the expression in Psalm 1:6 “…the way of the ungodly shall perish,” and the rebels of Psalm 2:12 who are said to “ …perish in the way.” We linger only to observe the further point that the “meditated” of Psalm 1:2 is closely analogous to “… take counsel together” in Psalm 2:2. Delitzsch warns against overdoing these parallels.[3]

Many expositors have noted the connection between the two ways of the Savior in Mt. 7:13, 14, and the two ways described here in such vivid contrast. It is not demonstrable that Jesus was thinking about this passage since the same general phenomenon may be widely observed in the Old Testament literature, especially the Psalter and Proverbs; yet it is certain that this is the general backdrop of our Lord’s thought. The charge of Joshua (Josh. 1:8) is very closely connected with the wording here, especially as it bears on the relation of the blessed life to meditation in the law of God. The relation of Jer. 17:5–8 to Psalm 1 is a problem, but it is fairly certain that there is a dependence.

Along with many others, Calvin expresses the view that Psalm 1 was placed at the beginning of the Psalter as a preface.[4] It is not too much to suggest that it was composed specifically for this purpose, although this is far from certain. In its own compressed style, the psalm paints in broad but beautiful strokes, a picture of human life. Such life either honors God and his law, or, by a grim logic of experience, comes to despise him. The theme expressed germinally here is reiterated throughout the book of Psalms and illustrated profusely in historical events elsewhere. The truly blessed life is inextricably connected with honoring God. To really believe this is to give our attention to the cultivation of personal piety. This is what the psalm is about.

We offer below an outline of the content of Psalm 1. It will be seen to have sermonic overtones.

Subject: Men Of Destiny

I. The Man of Blessing vv. 1–3

A. Negatively Considered

1. The blessed man refuses to listen to the counsel of ungodly men.

2. The blessed man refuses to make common cause with sinners.

3. The blessed man shuns the settled and aggressive despite of scorners.

B. Positively Considered

1. The blessed man finds delight in the law of the Lord.

2. The blessed man, as a habit of life, meditates in this law.

3. The blessed man is like a planted tree in a well-watered garden.

a. Fruitful (explicit)

b. Stable (implicit)

4. The blessed man is spiritually dynamic in prospering his affairs.

II. The Man of Cursing vv. 4–6

A. The ungodly man is marked by instability like chaff.

B. The ungodly man comes into the judgment of God.

C. The judgment of God on the ungodly man involves excommunication from spiritual privileges.

Conclusion: God will prosper the righteous man and destroy the wicked. True piety should therefore be cultivated.

I.

No attempt will be made to offer a full exposition of Psalm 1 along the lines we have suggested in the outline. We shall concentrate attention on certain key aspects of the psalm. One question that has received considerable discussion is whether the three verbs in verse one constitute a progression of some kind (climax), or whether they simply view the total compass of experience. The vast majority of interpreters are convinced that there is an escalation here. The intent is to show the insidiousness of evil. Infection begins gradually, but spreads swiftly. Sin does not stampede us into the bottomless pit of infidelity at once. The stages are fairly easy, and in this fact is implicit warning to those who flirt with evil. It is not necessary to insist that the climax is reflected in all three parts of the parallel clause, (i.e. including words for sinners and describing locale) but it is fairly obvious in the verbs. Even so, there is reflected in lus (scorner) a certain extreme situation. It indicates an ultimate in depravity. The word lus is commonly found in the book of Proverbs and its usage there makes it clear that great perversity is intended. To mock, deride, and scorn God, his people, and his word, surely represents something very radical.

Looking at the individual segments of the verse, we may observe that to walk “…in the counsel of the ungodly,” means to give attentive ear to earth-bound philosophies. It is not necessary to restrict the reference to formal counselling. It may very well refer to the subtle and deceitful character of attitudes unthinkingly appropriated. A great deal of harm comes from being unguarded in the presence of worldly thinking. This is but the beginning of sorrows. Calvin stresses that withdrawal from the society of the ungodly is required for any who wishes to apply his mind to meditation on the Word of God.[5] It cannot be properly denied that many are naive and simpleminded when it comes to understanding the stratagems of the Enemy. Not all can say with Paul that “…we are not ignorant of his (Satan’s) devices.” (2 Cor. 2:11). Careful attention to the verbal sequence here will make us better informed. The infectious power of sin cannot be ignored or belittled.

The expression “…standeth in the way of sinners,” may be thought of as conscious adoption of worldly attitudes, and the conforming of the life to the logical tyranny of unabashed secularism. It is no longer a case of occasional and intermittent wicked influence, but joining rank and making common cause with the ungodly. Not an inadvertent inconsistency, but a deliberate and reasoned attitude consciously adopted. The infatuation of sin makes the person a prisoner to his own depraved desires and evil imagination. He soon grows more and more settled in his luxury of self-indulgence.

The last member of the series pictures a man who comes at last to a certain obduracy and obstinacy that encourages the most vile and blasphemous attacks upon God and his people. If we take the Hebrew word as meaning assembly rather than seat, it carries the implication of deliberate plotting. Such a thought immediately calls up Psalm 2:2 where “…take counsel together” makes such a conception explicit. Alexander summarizes the steps of the climax as: (1) occasional conformity; (2) fixed association; and (3) established residence.[6]

II.

The expression “blessed” with which the psalm opens may be treated here as providing an appropriate transition to the positive traits of the godly man discussed below. Scholars have rightly related this to the beatitudes of our Lord in Mt. 5:1 ff. In this connection notice that the translation “happy” is definitely not happy. The loss in such a rendering is incalculable. It is difficult to avoid the comparatively superficial connotation of such an expression. Moreover, it seems fairly clear that even the familiar “Blessed is the man…” of the AV does less than justice to the Hebrew expression, which is an exclamation, a ringing cry of triumph. Much to be preferred is “O the blessedness of…”, or, “O the blessings of…”, depending on whether one understands the form ʾashere as a simple numerical plural or a plural of intensity. In either case the stress falls on the unique state of the righteous man. Alexander’s “How completely happy…” is comparatively vapid.[7]

III.

The positive elements of the description of the godly man are presented in the figure of the tree, a way of speaking not unfamiliar to the Old Testament. The palm as a stately and noble tree fits well the symbol of spiritual stature. It is an attractive emblem of spiritual life and productivity. The image of deliberate planting, perhaps in the garden of an estate, is the likely thought. The words palge mayim (rivers of water) properly refer here to artificially constructed water channels rather than to natural streams. Concrete spiritual virtues are pictured as fruit, and Jesus applies the same general thought to the vine in Jn. 15:1 ff. Fruit comes as a result of a vital, living relationship, and the point is clear that spirituality involves the presence of Christian character. The idea of stability is not explicit, but may be safely inferred.

IV.

The contrast between the godly and the ungodly is brought to sharp focus in verses five and six. The idea that “…the ungodly shall not stand in the judgment,” is not meant to deny a resurrection of the wicked dead as some have rather strangely supposed, but rather the inability of the sinner to endure the wrath of God is in view. Expositors disagree much about the judgment here referred to, some seeing it as eschatological, others as present. In either case the wicked man will not endure. His life is disoriented toward God and he is therefore afflicted with pernicious instability, (Isa. 57:20). The evil man buckles beneath the pressures of life through his inherent weakness, but he is also crushed by the millstone of heavenly justice.

Contrariwise, the righteous not only exult in present blessings, but know their future is bright with the assurances of God. The Lord “knoweth” their way. Much more than mere cognition is in view, for this does not distinguish the righteous above the wicked. Briggs sees in this expression a living, tender and intimate relation.[8] Though the word in certain contexts may mean “choose,” it probably does not reach that far here. It does, however, stand in natural contrast to the perishing of the wicked. In this manner the blessedness of true piety is accentuated.

Notes

  1. Charles A. Briggs, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Psalms. Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark 1907, Vol. I, p. 3.
  2. E. W. Hengstenberg, Commentary on the Psalms, Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1846, Vol. I, pp. 1-6.
  3. Franz Delitzsch, Biblical Commentary on the Psalms, T. and T. Clark, 1876, Vol. I, p. 82.
  4. John Calvin, Commentary on the Book of Psalms, Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1963 edition, p. 1.
  5. Ibiid, p. 2.
  6. J. A. Alexander, The Psalms, Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication, 1850, Vol. I., p. 2.
  7. Ibid.
  8. Briggs, Op. Cit. p. 7.

Spirit and Church

by Arthur M. Climenhaga

A Word Concerning the Holy Spirit

In His parting counsels the Lord Jesus Christ spoke freely of the Holy Spirit. This is significant in that one of the remarkable features of His earlier ministry was His comparative silence concerning the Holy Spirit. Earlier occasions were rare when He mentioned the Spirit and then always in circumstances which made the reference necessary — for example, the word to Nicodemus in John 3:15, again speaking of the power of prayer and giving of the Holy Spirit in Luke 11:13, and warning about the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. But now the shadow of the Cross falls over His path and in the fourteenth, fifteenth, and sixteenth chapters of John Jesus speaks in the Upper Room. In a few pregnant sentences He gathers up all that can be said of the Spirit’s relation to the Church, the World and God. Herein is to be found a summary statement of the doctrine of the Spirit as the Third Person of the Trinity.

Three outstanding truths concerning the Spirit underline these teachings of the Christ:

  1. The Spirit comes to take the place of Jesus Christ, to be to the disciples all that Christ had been and more than He would have become had He stayed with them.
  2. The Holy Spirit promised to the disciples is the selfsame Spirit who dwelt in the Christ and was the explanation of His earthly life and ministry.
  3. The Spirit comes to dwell in the disciples as He dwelt in Christ in order that Jesus Christ will be reproduced in the disciple thus making him what Christ would have been had He stayed on the earth and lived where that disciple lives.[1]

A Word Concerning the Church

Someone once spoke of history as biography “writ large.” Presumably he meant that to write in detail of a few leaders in any country or group is to write in essence of the history of that particular country or group. This is particularly true of sacred history.

The history of the early church is a composite of sketches in more or less detail of the lives of the early disciples and especially of two outstanding leaders, the Apostles Paul and Peter. These sketches are in the final analysis the recounting of the manifestation and working of the Holy Spirit among men during the several decades following the ascension of our Lord. This working of the Spirit among men redeemed by Jesus Christ and called out from a life of sin to a life of holiness is the recorded history of the formation of the Church. The Church then is the biography of its divinely-raised up, Holy Spirit filled and dominated disciples “writ large.”[2]

However, the Church is more than biography or history alone. It is to be understood only in terms of its genesis as a Christian Church, a body of “called out ones.” Historically the Church is linked with that Hebrew form, called in the Authorized Version of Acts 7:38, the church in the wilderness. The church of the Old Testament was the first representative of the ecclesia — the called out ones. It was indeed a community of the Spirit. Although manifested in natural and social laws, it was nevertheless a supernatural organization. As such it was the first step to the Christian Church in that it cultivated and matured that faith which finally issued in the Kingdom of God. It was the community which gave Christ to the world.

The second step towards the Church was the formation by our Lord of the “little flock.” Here we stand midway between the Mosaic economy and Pentecost. This flock was composed of two groups — the disciples clustering around John the Baptist and the group gathering around Jesus Himself. All of these believed that Jesus was the Messiah and formed the group in that informal organization who by their love for the Master and faith in His words were spiritually qualified to receive the gift of the Holy Spirit on the Day of Pentecost. These then were the true nucleus of the Church.[3]

Combining these two areas of consideration we come to

A Word Concerning the Church and Spirit

The day of Pentecost is so closely related to the early history of the Church that we are inclined to speak of it as the birthday of the Church. When we consider that the work of the Holy Spirit necessarily demanded an objective economy this is true. The day of Pentecost represented that new order of spiritual life on earth which, initiated by the advent of Christ, was now preserved by the perpetual indwelling of the Holy Spirit.

The Church is thus the creation of the Holy Spirit. It is a community of believers who owe their spiritual life from the first to last to the Spirit. Apart from the Holy Spirit there can be neither Christian nor church. For this reason we declare that the Christian faith is not institutional but experimental. It is not an ordained class, neither is it merely ordinances and sacraments. It is not a fellowship of common interest in service, virtue, or culture. Membership is by spiritual birth alone with the roll of membership kept in heaven. The door to this Church is Jesus Christ. He knows those that are His and they know Him. The church membership list and the Lamb’s Book of Life are not always identical. “No man can say, Jesus is Lord, but in the Holy Spirit,” and confession of the Lordship of Jesus Christ is the primary condition of membership in His Church.

The command to tarry in Jerusalem until the enduement of power from on high proves that the one essential equipment of the Church is the gift of the Holy Spirit. Nothing else will avail for the real work of the Church. In fact, the New Testament ideal of the Church is intensely spiritual. Thus while the Church was instituted by Jesus Christ during His earthly ministry, it was constituted by the outpouring of the Holy Spirit on the Day of Pentecost. The Church was a Spirit-filled, Spirit-empowered, Spirit-guided, Spirit-used body of Christian believers. It grew as the Holy Spirit was active in His operations upon both individuals and society in that day.

Further, the New Testament doctrine of the Church is centered in its spirituality. The Apostle Paul conceived of the Church as a social organism in which the Holy Spirit prevails.

He writes of the Church as the body of Christ (Romans 12:5; 1 Corinthians 12:27; Ephesians 1:23; 4:12; Colossians 1:24; 2:19). He also calls the Church the bride of Christ (Ephesians 5:23, 25; 2 Corinthians 11:2). And then concerning admission into the Church, he declares, “For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body, whether we be Jews or Gentiles, whether we be bound or free; and have been all made to drink into one Spirit.” (1 Corinthians 12:13). In a grand final word the Apostle John reports the risen Lord as saying, “And the Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. And let him that is athirst come. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.” (Revelation 22:17).

Again the objective of the Church’s activity is spiritual in its emphasis. Of this spiritual objective Paul writes to the Christians in Ephesus and neighboring churches: “There is one body, and one Spirit … And he gave some, apostles and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: Till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ.” (Ephesians 4:4, 11–13).[4]

What we are really saying here is that a clear and decisive line can be drawn between what we might call “the church of authority” and the “church of the Spirit.” As Dr. Frank Bateman Stanger puts it:

“The church of authority” is adhered to by those who are primarily concerned with a dogmatic expression of Christianity in an institution. “The church of authority” is a visible Church, characterized by stability, continuity, and legality. “The church of authority” proposes the way of conformity as the test of Christian loyalty, and insists upon the acceptance of the Christian religion as a governmental scheme. 

* * * * 

“The church of the Spirit” has been described as an inflowing, refreshing, penetrating tide. “The church of the Spirit,” in subordinating opinions to obedience and dogmatics to loyalty, makes the audacious assertion that often “the church of authority,” in its institutional procedure, has been tempted to take the wrong road; making central what was incidental, setting logic before life, speculation before inspiration, the letter before the Spirit.”[5]

Thus in our consideration of the Church and the Spirit we declare that for much that is undertaken by the Church the Holy Spirit is not needed. Religious services and organized institutions do not necessarily constitute a Christian Church and such may flourish without the activity of the Holy Spirit in their midst. Therefore, we are constrained to reverse the order of Church and Spirit and turn to

A Word Concerning Spirit and Church

In the course of this presentation, we should now see where we are moving. First we stated in brief our definition of the Holy Spirit. Then we did the same for the Church. In the wording of the third consideration, we deliberately stated it “Church and Spirit.” And just as deliberately now we state it “Spirit and Church.” For we have come to the point of asking ourselves what happens in the life of that Church when the Spirit is in it and works in it.

First of all, the Church will be a Spirit-controlled Church. The work of the Spirit in the Church is set forth in the promises of Jesus on the threshold of His ascension, demonstrated in the Acts of the Apostles, and amplified in selected sections of the New Testament letters. The Gospels record “All that Jesus began to do and to teach, until the day in which He was received up,” and the Acts of the Apostles tell of all that He continued to do and to teach after the day in which He was received up. This He did through the Holy Spirit who is the active, administrative Agent of the glorified Son. The Holy Spirit is the Paraclete, the Deputy, the Representative, the Vicar of the Ascended Christ. His mission on which He was sent by the Father and Son is to glorify Christ by perpetuating His character, establishing His Kingdom and accomplishing His redeeming purpose in the world. Since the Church is the Body of Christ, and the Spirit is the Spirit of Christ, He — the Holy Spirit — fills the Body, directs its movements, controls its members, inspires its wisdom, supplies its strength. The Spirit guides it into the truth, sanctifies its agents and empowers, calls, distributes, controls, guides, inspires, strengthens them for witness. Thus the work of the Church is to “minister in the Spirit,” to speak His message, and transmit His power.

The Spirit has never abdicated His authority nor will he relegate His power. The church that is man-managed instead of Spirit-governed is doomed to spiritual failure. A ministry that is theologically trained but not Spirit-filled works no miracles. It is possible to excel in mechanics and fail in dynamic. The root-trouble of the present distress is that the Church has more faith in the world and her own personal efforts than in the power of the Spirit. Things will become no better till we get back to the Spirit’s realized presence and power.[6]

In a very practical way, then, this brings us to consideration of a Spirit-Staffed Church. Summarizing the teachings of I Corinthians 12 relative to the various offices of the Church, we note that the Lord set in the Church: “First Apostles, second prophets, third teachers, then miracles, then gifts of healings, helps, governments, divers kinds of tongues.” (1 Cor. 12:28). In this same chapter in verse 11 the Holy Spirit is credited with dispensing gifts severally as He will. The gifts are enumerated as “the word of wisdom, the word of knowledge, faith, healing, working of miracles, prophecy, discerning of spirits, divers tongues, interpretation of tongues.”[7]

Now here are two lists, the one pertaining to offices and the other to the gifts. Even though the lists are separate and distinct there is some evidence of overlapping. And it is evident that while the staffing of the Church is the vital concern of the Trinity, yet the staffing is accomplished through the immediate ministry of the third person of the Trinity, the Holy Spirit. Thus the words of the Apostle Paul in Ephesians 4:11 and 12 assume importance: “And he gave some to be apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; for the perfecting of the saints, unto the work of ministering, unto the building up of the body of Christ.”

We do not conclude from this that a complete formula for church organization is supplied in the New Testament. The offices mentioned both in the Acts and in the writings of the Apostle Paul appear to have been arranged for as various situations arose demanding administrative solutions. We will not suggest that the Spirit’s imprimatur or particular blessing can be found on a congregational or presbyterial or episcopal form of church government. Rather, from the New Testament perspective we can lay down a principle for the guidance of the church at all times: Now as then, whatever the office to be filled, it is the Holy Spirit who is immediately and directly concerned.

Note with interest, therefore, that in the early organization of the Church, when the need arose for the selection of “members of the staff” — not to preach or to conduct what was considered to be the apostolic spiritual ministry — but to provide help for timid foreign windows, seven laymen were chosen to be deacons. One of the three prerequisites for the filling of the office of deacon was the statement that those chosen should be “full of the Spirit” (Acts 6:3). This is eloquent testimony to the importance of a Spirit-staffed church.

What is of major import then in the development of contemporary church life? Whatever the administrative policy of the church or whatever the technique employed in the selection of the spiritual leader of the local church, the all-important consideration is that church leaders and pastors should be appointed by the Holy Spirit. Spirit-filled pulpits is a continuing urgent need of the hour. The winning of men and women to Jesus as well as the building up of the body of Christ is dependent on Spirit-filled pulpits. We urge that if there are any other offices belonging to more modern churchly endeavor, even though not specifically mentioned in the New Testament, such offices must come within the category of the Spirit’s staffing.

The Holy Spirit is at work, ever and always at work. He is at work more markedly today through people, ordinary and extra-ordinary people. Without the Spirit working through the people of the Church, there is no life.

In elaboration of this Dr. Oswald J. Hoffman in the Reformation Sunday sermon at the Berlin World Congress on Evangelism so appropriately said of the Spirit in the Book of Acts,

In this story Luke tells how the Spirit works by witness, reaching out to the people beyond the church through Spirit-filled people in the church. It is not a story about church organization, or about church-state relations, or even about methods of evangelism. It is the story of how people filled with the Holy Spirit used every conceivable method to bring the Gospel to people who did not know the Lord Jesus Christ, that they might believe, be baptized and be saved. 

It is a story of proclamation and instruction, of how the Spirit of God uses the people of God to proclaim the Word of God to bring to birth new children of God by the Gospe.[8]

A Word Concerning the Unity of the Spirit

One of the major issues of the hour in the life of the Church is the matter of ecumenics. We are hearing so much these days about the ecumenical movement. It is not all good and it is not all bad. Let us not fool ourselves — everyone of us in some measure or form is interested or involved in some way in an ecumenical spirit. The lowliest independent nondenominational church that wants to support some sort of mission program will have to be incipiently ecumenical about it by supporting some faith or interdenominational mission program.

Some mean by ecumenicalism that we must get every Christian to unite with every other Christian, or every church to unite with every other church in one great organization. Some of us do not share that view. What is profoundly needed, however, is for the Church to have what Paul wrote about to the Ephesian church (Eph. 4): “The unity of the Spirit.” Union is one thing; unity another.

We do not plead for carnal divisions that too often may exist among us; yes, among us who name the name of Christ and claim the life of the Spirit. We do not plead for pettiness and bigotry. Rather, we plead for that life of the Spirit where all of us in the Church are ready to go to the cross and die to ourselves — die not only to our fleshly selves, but even to our ecclesiastical selves.

Here it is that the Spirit in the Church will work. The New Testament is replete with case-examples on which we can touch ever so briefly. We note three.[9]

Case number one. In Acts 15:1–35 you have an issue before the Jerusalem Council. At stake was not a question of administrative procedure but rather the essence of the Gospel : Is the Gospel for Gentiles or only for Jews; if for the Gentiles too, must they conform to Jewish rites and customs?

Four significant facts stand out in the solution to this threatened rupture of the Church which reveal the working of the Spirit in keeping the unity of the body.

First, we note that a group representative of the whole church settled the matter. Paul and Barnabas did not start a Pauline church at Antioch on lines of freedom for Gentiles, thus abandoning a Petrine church at Jerusalem to Judaizing tendencies. Second, all parties recognized the sovereignty of the Holy Spirit. To the question, “In what way is the Holy Spirit actually at work today in the world?” Paul and Barnabas brought in field evidence. Thus it was obvious to the Jerusalem Council that the Holy Spirit was really at work among the Gentiles. They had the same spiritual blessings without the Jewish rites. So in substance the decision was rendered: It is our task to cooperate with the Holy Spirit where and as He is at work. Third, the Council listened to the Scriptures. The Apostle James in his summation quoted the Scriptures. Thus the Scriptures are our rule of faith in that they reveal the mind of the Spirit. Fourth, as a result of settling the main issue as being determined by the Holy Spirit through His Word and obvious work, everyone was willing to be generous to the feelings and even the prejudices of others in matters less important or secondary. What then do we learn in all this? We learn the graciousness of allowing liberty to others in non-essentials, with the assurance that if the Church cooperates with the Holy Spirit such non-essentials will fall off like so many dead leaves in due course.

Case number two is the clear-cut personality clash between Paul and Barnabas in Acts 15:36–41. Here we have a giant character, Paul, capable of tremendous self-discipline. This made him often seem severe in his dealings with others. But there is also something towering and magnificent about him as a result which makes his effect on history one of the greatest, if not the greatest, outside of Jesus Christ. Here we have also Barnabas, a “son of consolation.” What loving nuances there are in his character. And the two disagree over a weak, homesick boy, who, despite it all, has great potential. In the final sense probably both were wrong and both were right. The thing that counts is that they both agreed in the Spirit to disagree and to carry on in diverse courses the work of the Spirit.

Case number three. We turn to the rebuke by Paul to Peter as reported in Galatians 2:11–16. Peter had failed to be true to his vision and Paul administered the rebuke. When one remembers Peter’s later commendation of Paul’s letter one has a feeling that the work of the Spirit in Peter was to be seen.

Let us suppose in any of the above cases that the decisions effected or the course of action taken would have been the opposite of the one that pertained. What should Paul and Barnabas have done at Jerusalem? What should Paul have done if Peter would not have listened to him? Should they have gone along with positions which violated their consciences in order to preserve unity, or should they have separated? This is one of the most important questions of the hour.

First, of course, the answer must be Scriptural. An answer must never be born either of expediency or compromise. We must see the Scriptures in their wholeness and interpret them with a sound exegesis. Undoubtedly we will have times when separation is called for and becomes a virtue. Again, there are also times when to suffer through a bad situation is redemptive. This is where we must be shut up to the guidance of the Spirit to make application of a general truth which is held in tension between the two poles of any given particular case.

In conclusion, we summarize by declaring that the resources of the Church are in “the supply of the Spirit.” The Holy Spirit is more than a Minister of Consolation. He is in reality the Christ to the Church without the limitations of the flesh and the material world. The Spirit can reveal what Christ could not speak. The Spirit has resources of power greater than those Jesus Christ in His incarnation could use, and thus the Spirit makes possible greater works than Christ’s. To the Church He is the Spirit of God, the Spirit of Truth, the Spirit of Witness, the Spirit of Conviction, the Spirit of Power, the Spirit of Holiness, the Spirit of Life, the Spirit of Adoption, the Spirit of Help, the Spirit of Liberty, the Spirit of Wisdom, the Spirit of Revelation, the Spirit of Promise, the Spirit of Love, the Spirit of Meekness, the Spirit of Glory, and the Spirit of Prophecy.[10]

The Church is called to explore the resources of the Spirit, for the resources of the world of itself alone are futile. And the resources of the Church — these are inadequate! A man-managed, world-annexing church can never save the world or fulfill the mission of Christ. Let the Church seek the fulness of the Spirit — in the Spirit is abundance of wisdom, resources, and power!

Notes

  1. Samuel Chadwick, Humanity and God (New York: Revell, d.), p. 142 f.
  2. J. A. Huffman, The Holy Spirit (Marion, Indiana: The Standard Press), Chapter X, see p. 195 f.
  3. H. Orton Wiley, Christian Theology (Kansas City, Missouri: Beacon Hill Press), Vol. III, pp. 103-111. Also, cf. Ibid., Vol. II, pp. 303307.
  4. Frank Bateman Stanger, “The Church of the Spirit,” in Further Insights Into Holiness, Kenneth Geiger, compiler, chapter 13. Note particularly pp. 214-216. Also, cf. H. Orton Wiley and Paul T. Culbertson, Introduction to Christian Theology (Kansas City, Missouri: Beacon Hill Press), chapter XX.
  5. Ibid., p. 213 f.
  6. Samuel Chadwick, The Way to Pentecost (Ft. Washington, Pennsylvania: Christian Literature Crusade, 1960), p. 12 f.
  7. Huffman, op. cit. pp. 200-211.
  8. Oswald J. Hoffman, “The Work of the Holy Spirit in Acts,” summarized for Decision from mimeographed article as presented to the World Congress on Evangelism, West Berlin, Germany, October 31, 1966.
  9. Cf. Everett Lewis Cattell, The Spirit of Holiness (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1963), chapter 6.
  10. Chadwick, op. cit., p. 16 f.

Take My Life and Let it Be [with lyrics for congregations]